Being a collector of Demonstrator, Yellow and White pens, I use the washable Sheaffer Skrip inks in these pens almost exclusively. I've never had a problem cleaning out one of these pens after using it. In my other pens, I like the Private Reserve Inks, particularly the Lake Placid Blue.
Lake Placid Blue is one of my top 5 inks. I use it almost exclusively in my blue Vanishing Point. A great ink in a very smooth pen. What a combination!
I got a snail today that was partiallly written using vintage Skrip. As another coincidence, I found at an antique place, a 16oz bottle of Scrip in washable black. It's about a third full and the bottle and label are near mint. Not bad for $8.95
I am also a fan of Private Reserve Inks and Lake Placid Blue is one of my favorites. I discovered Sheaffer Skrip Permanent Jet Black recently and I prefer its writing characteristics to Noodler's Black. My only qualm with it is that it doesn't seem to dry quite as black as I would like, as though it's just a bit grayer than black. I haven't run any tests comparing it to Aurora Black, which is my favorite black ink, but that's my impression.
Peter, is the Swisher mignight black a washable ink or permanent. I like the idea of a fast drying ink, but not at the expense of permanently darkening the barrel of my vacumatic.
Gerard.
__________________
If you are what you eat, then I'm easy, fast and cheap!
It's a Noodlers ink. I don't see anything washable about it. I very vaguely remember something about Nathan Tardif (creator of Noodlers) having or used to have a prize for anyone who could successfully lift his ink from a check after it had been signed with Noodlers or something like that.
__________________
Tu ne cede malis sed contra audentior ito ~Yield not to misfortunes, but advance all the more boldly against them
dennis, are you sure swisher M Black is not washable??
this is swisher comments on th noodlers black:
NOODLER'S BOTTLED FOUNTAIN PEN INK (3 oz)
This Noodler's Ink Bottled Fountain Pen Ink is currently available in 36 + colors, making it a very economically priced bottle of fountain pen ink.
We have found the black ink to be extremely water resistant when applied to paper and allowed to dry. However, unlike some permanent inks that will damage your pens if allowed to dry on the nib and feed, this ink can be removed with water (distilled water is recommended if ink is allowed to dry on the nib and feed). None of the other colors are as water resistant as the black, but all were developed to write on most common types of paper without a lot of feathering.
The manufacturer has indicated this ink is safe for use in most fountain pens but may cause staining on some materials.
NOTE: The Black Ink listed here is the same Black Ink listed under the Waterproof Ink.
this is swisher comment on their brand (by noodlers) midnight black:
SWISHER PENS BOTTLED FOUNTAIN PEN INK Swisher Pens Bottled Fountain Pen Ink was developed for us by Nathan Tardif (he also makes Noodler's ink) as a quick drying ink which was intended for use on good quality paper, Vellum (Rhodia Tablets), Linen (International Paper - Beckett Cambric Writing) and many other types of paper (see list below for our favorite types of paper to use with these inks). It can used on most other grades of paper, but some feathering may occur when used in a pen with a "wet" nib. In our tests, we found the black to be darker than most (if not all) conventional black inks we sell (Noodler's black was the closest). It should also be noted that our ink dries almost instantaneously when used on some types of paper. This has been proven to be very beneficial to left-handed writers. When tested on several popular brand of Vellum, Linen and Pure Cotton papers, our ink took approximately 14 seconds to dry to where it was "smudge" free. When tested on Cambridge writing paper, it took about 2 seconds for this ink to dry. (Drying times may vary due to humidity and type of paper used).
unless i'm missing something, they do mention the water resistance of the noodlers black, but not of the swisher brand... although they are both made by noodlers.