Welcome to- The Fountain Pen Community!

Members Login
Post Info TOPIC: Skrip Red vs Noodler's Nikita Red showdown


Experienced

Status: Offline
Posts: 95
Date:
Skrip Red vs Noodler's Nikita Red showdown
Permalink Closed


Noodlers Nikita vs Sheaffer Skrip Red

-Take 2- (thanks to Inka for pointing out a major error in Take 1!)

These two red inks have just about everything I need in an ink.  There are some subtle difference between them, which I look at here.  I've photographed my samples--I think this gives a better sense of the color as opposed to a scan, which doesn't always look the same on different browsers/OSes.

Picture, with transcription below:
4338345029_6cb3231132_o.jpg

Noodler's Nikita Red
A "true" red, although a touch more faded or pink than Skrip Red.  Fairly quick to dry, especially for a Noodler's ink.  Slight feathering on crummy paper.  I thought this was a bulletproof/waterproof ink, but a quick run under the faucet reveals otherwise--it is most certainly NOT waterproof (thanks for pointing that out, Scott!).  Even though it isn't waterproof, it is more colorfast than Skrip Red.

Sheaffer Skrip Red (current formulation)
Another popping "true" red.  I think Skrip Red is a bit more saturated/vibrant than Nikita.  It is superb on cheapo paper quality--hardly any feathering.  It is not at all waterproof.  Skrip always washes away easily which is bad for papers but good for pens.  It has never stained my Pelikan ink window or Lamy Al-Star converter.  I wouldn't hesitate to put it in a demonstrator if I ever get one.

Conclusion
It has to be a draw, in my opinion.  Skrip has the advantage on cheap paper.  Noodler's has the advantage when it comes to water (note: it is not waterproof!).  Both are true reds that dry quickly and perform well on cheap paper.  Both are good chices for Valentine's Day, Christmas Cards, or grading papers.

Swatch close-up:
4338345087_879c3d53cd_o.jpg

Water test:
4339087578_7b97b450c1_o.jpg




-- Edited by bphollin on Sunday 7th of February 2010 04:37:15 PM

__________________


Experienced

Status: Offline
Posts: 95
Date:
Permalink Closed

Corrected review now posted!

__________________


Seasoned

Status: Offline
Posts: 140
Date:
Permalink Closed

Excellent review, thanks!!!!!!!!!!!
I especially like the swabs, really gives a good perspective on the difference in saturation between the two inks.

I made a nice "blood red" ink blend back in March, 2009, using a bit of The Heart Of Darkness [I estimate maybe a 10:1 ratio of Nikita to THOD?].
That little bit of "bulletproof" black really made it stay, a nice deep red color too.
Took me awhile to find it, but here's a shot of my Nikita/THOD blend, including wash-tests of pure Nikita [on lower right] and the "bloody" blend [on lower left]..

Nikita_plus_HoD_Blend.jpg


Nikita_plus_HoD_Blend_Wash_.jpg

-- Edited by InkaFX on Monday 8th of February 2010 09:34:58 AM

__________________
"None of us can have as many virtues as the fountain-pen, or half its cussedness; but we can try."
~Mark Twain~

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard